Обсуждение:Герб Польши
Проект «Геральдика» (уровень III, важность для проекта высшая)
Эта статья тематически связана с вики-проектом «Геральдика», цель которого — создание и улучшение статей по темам, связанным с геральдикой. Вы можете её отредактировать, а также присоединиться к проекту, принять участие в его обсуждении и поработать над требуемыми статьями. |
Deficiencies in the article
правитьThe article fails to mention that the current emblem closely follows the design established in 1927 (only minor corrections to the drawing have been done in 1990).
Also, near the end of the article there is some bullshit written that the crown was supposedly "officially" removed in 1943, by some communist guerillas. First, that is a contradiction in itself, because these guerillas were not "official" by definition (the only official - i.e. government-approved - military organization in Poland under the German/Soviet occupation was the Home Army, Armia Krajowa). Second, despite that, the official government (in London) has never removed the crown. What some Soviet agents did with the emblem in 1943 does not matter at all. 78.8.92.176 09:24, 28 мая 2015 (UTC)
- Why it is not matter? --Azgar 10:28, 28 мая 2015 (UTC)
- It equally matters as if it was me doing "official" changes to the emblem of Russia. If I do this now, will you take this information seriously and put it into the relevant article? 78.8.92.176 12:01, 29 мая 2015 (UTC)
-- "Официально же корона была убрана с герба польского государства в 1943 г., когда руководство Гвардии Людовой пересмотрело прежнюю государственную символику"
As written above, the word "Официально" in this text is blatant Soviet propaganda: the only instance able to make "official" changes to the Polish coat of arms in 1943 was the legal government (in London). How long will it take you to fix it, notorious liars?
- Soviets proclaimed new government. Azgar (обс.) 08:42, 6 декабря 2017 (UTC)
- Illegally, so who cares.
- Polska Rzeczpospolita Ludowa was recognized by UN and almost all states in the world. Your vandalism will be rolled out. Azgar (обс.) 09:27, 1 марта 2018 (UTC)
- Illegally, so who cares.